Wisconsin Badgers defensive end Isaiah Mullens (99) runs through a drill during fall training camp at Camp Randall Stadium in Madison on Thursday, Aug. 10, 2023.
Known for running a 3-3-5 scheme, Tressel faces the unique challenge this offseason of “meshing the elite,” meaning how does he blend Wisconsin’s size and pass-rushing ability with his propensity to run a heavy man coverage system?
Much like our offensive exercise, we’re going to examine which defensive position groups have evolved or declined over the last calendar year.
Let’s begin.
Defensive Line
The Badgers defensive line was a strength in 2022, largely because Keeanu Benton was an absolute game-wrecker at nose tackle. Rodas Johnson, James Thompson Jr., and Isaiah Mullens each showed flashes and were competent rotation pieces but never provided a genuine compliment to Benton.
In 2023, with Benton off to the NFL, there’s nowhere for this group to go but down. Johnson, Thompson Jr., and Mullens are all back in the fold, and Wisconsin football also added transfer Darian Varner into the mix. This group can still be solid this season but won’t likely produce a ton of playmakers, so I have to go worse for that reason.
Verdict: Worse
Wisconsin Football Inside Linebackers
Wisconsin has a storied tradition of producing exceptional inside linebackers — but 2022 was the first season where it got good — not great play at ILB in a few years. Maema Njongmeta was really good, Jordan Turner showed flashes and came on strong at the end, and Jake Chaney showed some serous playmaking ability.
The best part? They’re all back in 2023.
The depth and experience of this position group should make it one of the most important and productive position groups on the roster. I like the top trio quite a bit and think they’re poised to make some noise this season.
Verdict: Better
Wisconsin Football Outside Linebackers
In 2022, the Badgers had an absolute star at outside linebacker in Nick Herbig to get after opposing quarterbacks and wreak havoc on offensive lines. But UW didn’t get a ton of production alongside him from CJ Goetz, Darryl Peterson, or Kaden Johnson.
This brings me to my glass-half-empty answer: I think the outside linebacker room will be worse in 2023. Goetz, Bollers, and Peterson are all positioned to see the field this season. Johnson and Jeff Pietrowski could also work their way in. Wisconsin football has enough talent here to create pressure — but there isn’t a DUDE in this room for the first time in a while.
Verdict: Worse
Cornerbacks
The Badgers brought in three transfer defensive backs last offseason to slot into the starting lineup — and they were fine. Nothing more, nothing less.
In 2023, there have been changes, getting back a healthy Alexander Smith and new players, such as Ricardo Hallman, stepping into key starting roles. But the depth wasn’t there — so UW went portaling and brought in Jason Maitre, Nyzier Fourqurean, and Mike Mack II to help round out the two deep. There are also a few talented freshmen that could work their way into the rotation.
While the secondary has potential, it may take time for the new players to develop chemistry and experience. Overall, the position group is one that I view as an upgrade but will entirely depend on its starters’ health.
Verdict: Better
Safeties
Wisconsin football had a similar safety group last season — but injuries ravaged the position group and forced them to make do with whatever was healthy. Travian Blaylock missed the entire season, and Hunter Wohler missed a good chunk because of injury as well. Kamo’i Latu emerged as a heat-seeking missile on the backend that was a difference maker. They were good last season — but could have been better.
In 2023, they return everyone from last year and are completely healthy, rolling into week one. The Badgers also have up-and-coming safety Austin Brown, who could also factor into the mix. With four playable, talented safeties — this room is definitely improved and even has a couple of third-team options to be excited about.
Sep 22, 2023; West Lafayette, Indiana, USA; Wisconsin Badgers running back Chez Mellusi (1) is taken off the field in a cart after suffering an injury during the second half at Ross-Ade Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Robert Goddin-USA TODAY Sports
The injury looked bad on replay, but the cart coming out for the former Clemson transfer, along with an air cast being placed on his leg, heightened fears for the worst. Ultimately, it was confirmed that Mellusi would miss the rest of the 2023 season with a fractured fibula.
Mellusi’s fracture marked his third significant injury during his tenure with the Badgers. He was named the starter in 2021 after transferring in from Clemson but ultimately suffered a season-ending ACL tear. He would return for his 2022 campaign but miss four games in the middle of the season due to a broken arm. Now, just four games into the season, Mellusi will miss the final eight games of the regular season.
Where Does Wisconsin Football Go From Here?
Without Mellusi, UW will look to its young talent to replicate his production, which could be challenging. The fifth-year senior logged 51 carries for 307 yards and four touchdowns through four games. He also tacked on three receptions for 12 yards.
Mellusi did earn a bulk of the carries through four games, with Braleon Allen dinged up. Luckily, Allen looks to be back to his usual self, so they won’t need to rely on a younger back to take the majority of the carries. Still, the depth is a big question mark for Wisconsin’s running back room now.
Behind Allen, the Badgers have Jackson Acker, Cade Yacamelli, Grover Bortolotti, and Nate White to fill out the rotation.
Acker, a redshirt sophomore, has sparingly seen some time on the field as the RB3. The Madison native has appeared in three games thus far, logging eight carries for 31 yards as well as one reception for three yards. As the RB3, he’ll be expected to step up in the wake of Mellusi’s injury when Allen needs a breather.
Converted safety Cade Yacamelli will be the likely candidate to fill Acker’s shoes in the RB3 role. He hasn’t appeared in any offensive snaps thus far, but he has seen some time on the field with special teams. Reports out of spring and fall camp indicated that Yacamelli had something in the tank as a running back, but it remains to be seen in live game reps.
It’s not the best situation for Wisconsin to be in, but UW does have plenty of contributors at tailback who could take some snaps if need be. Although this situation is a tough one all around, there could be a bright spot.
Chez Mellusi Could Return to the Wisconsin Football Program in 2024
Since Mellusi sustained his injury during the fourth game of the season, Badger fans shouldn’t rule out a sixth-year return from the standout tailback.
Although Mellusi didn’t see starter-level snaps during his time with Clemson, he never used a redshirt year. Plus, his sophomore season was impacted due to the COVID-19 pandemic, giving him another year of eligibility.
So, the choice for Mellusi comes down to focusing on his health and looking to sign with an NFL team as a UDFA or moving on to the next phase of his life outside of football. On the other hand, he could return for a sixth year to boost his draft stock. It certainly wouldn’t hurt Wisconsin, who is looking at Allen potentially heading to the NFL draft after the season and having an influx of young running backs coming into the fold, such as Darrion Dupree, Dilin Jones, and Gideon Ituka.
Although Mellusi’s injury is devastating for a number of reasons, there is a small bright spot in that we could see him don the cardinal and white one more time.
Wisconsin is now headed into the bye week starting 3-1 on the season. They’ll take on Rutgers on October 7th in Madison as both teams look to improve to 4-1.
Sep 22, 2023; West Lafayette, Indiana, USA; Wisconsin Badgers defensive end James Thompson Jr. (90) celebrates after sacking Purdue Boilermakers quarterback Hudson Card (1) during the first half at Ross-Ade Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Robert Goddin-USA TODAY Sports
In this post-game recap, we dissect the performance of the Wisconsin Badgers by analyzing their snap counts and Pro Football Focus (PFF) grades for each position group — and include a few stats that help add context to the ole eye test.
By analyzing these metrics, we can gain a clearer insight into the individual contributions of each unit to the team’s overall performance. While you can’t take these figures as gospel, this allows us to identify strengths, key contributors, and areas where Wisconsin football excelled.
Let’s dive in.
Wisconsin Football Defensive Snap Counts & PFF Grades
Purdue Boilermakers wide receiver TJ Sheffield (8) is tackled by a group of Wisconsin Badgers players during the NCAA football game, Friday, Sept. 22, 2023, at Ross-Ade Stadium in West Lafayette, Ind. Wisconsin Badgers won 38-17.
Defensive Line:
Rodas Johnson – Snap Count: [36] – PFF Grade: [47.4]
James Thomspon – Snap Count: [35] – PFF Grade: [64.6]
The most peculiar thing about Wisconsin football beating Purdue on Friday night was senior inside linebacker Maema Njongmeta essentially not playing at all. Full disclosure: I didn’t notice it until somebody pointed it out — but he appeared to see the field for one snap on fourth down late in the game. Luke Fickell said he was available — and I have a hard time believing something more isn’t going on here — but I guess we’ll have to wait and see.
The safety rotation was also somewhat bizarre to me for several reasons: Travian Blaylock sat in favor of a heavy dosage of Preston Zachman. I was also disappointed that Austin Brown couldn’t build off a strong performance against Georgia Southern.
I don’t need to get super in-depth on this one, but the defensive front seven was BAD. James Thompson Jr. is quickly becoming a stud on the defensive line — but other than him — there weren’t any individual performances to write home about. Nobody on the Wisconsin football defense registered more than two pressures on the night, and the Badgers finished with 16 total.
Lastly, a Wisconsin Badgers defense that’s struggled with giving up chunk plays all season (bottom third in the NCAA) also has a huge tackling issue — and was credited with 16 missed tackles as a team. This Wisconsin football defense isn’t talented enough to overcome these sloppy mistakes and is a clear point of emphasis to clean up during the bye week.
Sep 22, 2023; West Lafayette, Indiana, USA; Wisconsin Badgers head coach Luke Fickell look on prior to the start of the game at Ross-Ade Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Robert Goddin-USA TODAY Sports
On Friday night, Wisconsin Football laid down a 21-point victory in their Big Ten Conference opener against Purdue; now, the Badgers sit outside the top 25 in the AP polls with a 3-1 record (1-0 Big Ten) heading into a Week 5 bye before taking on Rutgers.
Wisconsin Football Falls Outside the Top 25 in Updated SP+ Rankings
For anyone unfamiliar with the ESPN SP+ model, it’s not your father’s associated press top 25 poll. It’s a forward-facing, Predictive model that serves as a tempo and opponent-adjusted measure of efficiency.
With that out of the way, the Week 4 SP+ rankings currently have Wisconsin football as the No. 27 team in the country — down two spots from last week. According to the metric, the Badgers have an overall grade of 13.2, with the No. 39 offense, No. 18 defense, and No. 4 special teams unit.
Other notable Big Ten programs in the SP+ top 10 include Michigan (1), Ohio State (3), and Penn State (10).
When the Badgers come out of the bye week, Wisconsin football begins a tough stretch of games against Rutgers, Iowa, Illinois, and Ohio State. Let’s hope the coaching staff can make necessary defensive adjustments, clean up the penalties on offense, and work in the younger running backs who must fill the No. 2 role after losing Chez Mellusi for the season.